| Rufus King | 1867–1872 |
| J. M. Walden | 1867–1868 |
| H. M. Storrs | 1867–1868 |
| J. B. Powell | 1867–1868 |
| M. D. Hanover | 1867–1869 |
| Robert Brown, Jr. | 1867–1870 |
| Henry Probasco | 1868–1870 |
| Hermann E. Eckel | 1868–1880 |
| Francis Ferry |
1869–1870, 1882–1885
|
| William B. Davis | 1870–1872 |
| William Tilden | 1870–1873 |
| Joseph P. Carbery | 1871–1873 |
| William Strunk | 1871–1873 |
| Leonard W. Goss | 1872–1881 |
| Moses F. Wilson | 1873–1875 |
| William J. O’Neil | 1873–1876 |
| Henry Mack | 1874–1874 |
| F. A. Armstrong | 1874–1876 |
| Alexander Long | 1874–1880 |
| George H. Pendleton | 1875–1878 |
| William H. Mussey | 1876–1881 |
| Charles Bird | 1877–1880 |
| Isaac Simon | 1879–1881 |
| Henry Garlick | 1879–1882 |
| Isaac Adler | 1881–1884 |
| Charles G. Jenner | 1881–1884 |
| E. Cort Williams | 1882–1882 |
| George Emig | 1882–1890 |
| James Brown | 1883–1885 |
| Howard Douglas | 1883–1886 |
| Daniel Finn | 1883–1887 |
| Thomas McLaughlin | 1885–1886 |
| William S. Thornton | 1885–1886 |
| Thomas Lee | 1886–1887 |
| George O. Deckebach | 1887–1888 |
| Louis L. Sadler | 1887–1894 |
| L. M. Hadden | 1887–1890 |
| Charles W. Whiteley | 1887–1890 |
| H. H. Mithoefer |
1888–1890, 1897–1901
|
| F. C. Zumstein | 1888–1890 |
| T. E. Taggart | 1890–1890 |
| Washington T. Forter | 1891–1933 |
| Adolph Fluemer | 1891–1896 |
| William Rendigs | 1891–1891 |
| J. R. Sayler | 1891–1891 |
| J. H. Charles Smith | 1891–1893 |
| William A. Hopkins | 1891–1900 |
| R. H. West | 1891–1930 |
| Andrew L. Herrlinger | 1892–1895 |
| Thornton M. Hinkle | 1892–1896 |
| Dr. Thomas P. White | 1894–1901 |
| E. R. Monfort | 1896–1897 |
| James A. Green | 1898–1955 |
| Herman Knost | 1901–1907 |
| Eugene Schaefer | 1901–1923 |
| Drausin Wulsin | 1902–1911 |
| Dr. Henry Wald Bettman | 1902–1933 |
| Charles W. Handman | 1911–1930 |
| Ernest Von Bargen | 1911–1923 |
| N. H. Hargrave | 1924–1924 |
| Agnes Hilton | 1924–1940 |
| Louise Pollak | 1925–1931 |
| Walter A. Draper | 1930–1933 |
| Morison R. Waite | 1930–1938 |
| Dr. Willard D. Halnes | 1933–1938 |
| Frank S. Bonham | 1933–1947 |
| George F. Eyrich | 1933–1948 |
| Ina Warner Broeman | 1933–1964 |
| Frederick W. Schwenck | 1938–1947 |
| Robert A. Black | 1939–1959 |
| Alfred T. Geisler | 1940–1944 |
| Judge Oliver M. Dock | 1944–1961 |
| Norman P. Auburn | 1947–1951 |
| Harry J. Finke, Jr. | 1947–1967 |
| Andrew F. Wiley | 1949–1966 |
| John T. Nolan, Jr. | 1951–1983 |
| George C. Eyrich | 1955–1962 |
| Richard R. Deupree, Jr. | 1959–1973 |
| Joseph S. Stern, Jr. | 1961–2003 |
| Nora May Nolan | 1962–1976 |
| Lawrence A. Kane, Jr. | 1964–1996 |
| Asa I. Atkins | 1966–1972 |
| Charles W. Anness | 1967–2006 |
| Dr. Peter Garvin | 1972–1998 |
| Kyle F. Brooks | 1973–1979 |
| Dorothy S. Hermanies | 1976–1999 |
| Donald H. Rolf | 1979–1982 |
| Charles D. Lindberg | 1982–2008 |
| Bailey W. Turner | 1984–2007 |
| Deliaan A. Gettler | 2003–2010 |
| Tara L. Khoury | 1999–2011 |
| Paul G. Sittenfeld | 2009–2015 |
| Allen G. Zaring IV | 2010–2017 |
| Ross A. Wright | 2007–2017 |
| William J. Moran | 1996–2019 |
| Elizabeth H. LaMacchia | 1998–2021 |
| Robert G. Hendon | 2006– |
| Barbara W. Trauth | 2011–2018 |
| Monica Donath Kohnen | 2015–2022 |
| Karen R. Clemons | 2017– |
| Diane Cunningham Redden | 2018– |
| Nadine Allen | 2018– |
| Gregory W. Olson | 2020– |
| Chris Harding | 2021– |
| Colleen Reynolds | 2022– |